Discussion:
Cedric on PoA movie?
(too old to reply)
dennisjcc =
2004-06-10 14:49:14 UTC
Permalink
Was that Cedric following Harry at the quidditch match? The one that
was hit by lightning?
Sinestro
2004-06-10 14:56:18 UTC
Permalink
Post by dennisjcc =
Was that Cedric following Harry at the quidditch match? The one that
was hit by lightning?
No WB has said the casting of Cedric happened after filming of PoA
dennisjcc =
2004-06-11 00:58:21 UTC
Permalink
Post by Sinestro
Post by dennisjcc =
Was that Cedric following Harry at the quidditch match? The one that
was hit by lightning?
No WB has said the casting of Cedric happened after filming of PoA
So, who's character was following Harry at the Quidditch match on the
movie? Harry and that 'character' were both flying after the snitch,
it follows that the 'character' following him is also a seeker, right?

That Quidditch match is between Gryffindor and Hufflepuff, right?
Now, who's the seeker(and captain) of the Hufflepuff team? Isn't it
Diggory?!
pdd
2004-06-11 14:51:38 UTC
Permalink
Post by dennisjcc =
Post by Sinestro
Post by dennisjcc =
Was that Cedric following Harry at the quidditch match? The one that
was hit by lightning?
No WB has said the casting of Cedric happened after filming of PoA
So, who's character was following Harry at the Quidditch match on the
movie? Harry and that 'character' were both flying after the snitch,
it follows that the 'character' following him is also a seeker, right?
That Quidditch match is between Gryffindor and Hufflepuff, right?
Now, who's the seeker(and captain) of the Hufflepuff team? Isn't it
Diggory?!
Yes, in the books. Who knows in the movie? None of the movies have
followed the book as far as the Quidditch teams go. Slytherin's team
in book 1 had no girls, but there was at least one in the movie. They
didn't even say in the movie which team Gryffindor was playing. Yes,
it was Hufflepuff in the book, but maybe not in the movie.
Jonathan Clements
2004-06-11 16:18:56 UTC
Permalink
Post by pdd
Post by dennisjcc =
Post by Sinestro
Post by dennisjcc =
Was that Cedric following Harry at the quidditch match? The one that
was hit by lightning?
No WB has said the casting of Cedric happened after filming of PoA
So, who's character was following Harry at the Quidditch match on the
movie? Harry and that 'character' were both flying after the snitch,
it follows that the 'character' following him is also a seeker, right?
That Quidditch match is between Gryffindor and Hufflepuff, right?
Now, who's the seeker(and captain) of the Hufflepuff team? Isn't it
Diggory?!
Yes, in the books. Who knows in the movie? None of the movies have
followed the book as far as the Quidditch teams go. Slytherin's team
in book 1 had no girls, but there was at least one in the movie. They
didn't even say in the movie which team Gryffindor was playing. Yes,
it was Hufflepuff in the book, but maybe not in the movie.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but is it possible to tell what teams were
playing by the colours? (If the movie even sticks to that element of it,
that is!).

Jon.
Fish Eye no Miko
2004-06-12 04:57:51 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jonathan Clements
They didn't even say in the movie which team Gryffindor was playing.
Yes, it was Hufflepuff in the book, but maybe not in the movie.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but is it possible to tell what teams
were playing by the colours? (If the movie even sticks to that
element of it, that is!).
Yes. They were in yellow; it was indeed Hufflepuff.

Catherine Johnson.
--
fenm at cox dot net
"Listen to you two, arguing like an old married couple."
-Snape, to Remus and Sirius, _Harry Potter and the Prisoner of
Azkaban_.
dennisjcc =
2004-06-12 00:46:40 UTC
Permalink
Post by pdd
Yes, in the books. Who knows in the movie? None of the movies have
followed the book as far as the Quidditch teams go. Slytherin's team
in book 1 had no girls, but there was at least one in the movie. They
didn't even say in the movie which team Gryffindor was playing. Yes,
it was Hufflepuff in the book, but maybe not in the movie.
The guy following Harry IS wearing Hufflepuff robes! Beaters and
Chasers, nor the Keepers don't go after the snitch, right? ONLY the
seekers!
C***@nospam.com
2004-06-12 04:23:22 UTC
Permalink
Post by pdd
Yes,
it was Hufflepuff in the book, but maybe not in the movie.
given that students graduate every year, those not in the know will
just assume (provided they even remember that it was Hufflepuff in that
scene) that the old seeker is gone and Cedric is the new one. so long
as no one brings up how long he was the team seeker, then folks will
buy it. at least those that don't have the books memorized
dennisjcc =
2004-06-13 12:25:29 UTC
Permalink
Post by Sinestro
Post by dennisjcc =
Was that Cedric following Harry at the quidditch match? The one that
was hit by lightning?
No WB has said the casting of Cedric happened after filming of PoA
Maybe he's only an extra playing as Cedric. Because definitely, that
character following Harry IS Cedric...

Continue reading on narkive:
Loading...